A Hero is someone who looks out for the benefits of others and is a kind, honest person who improves the situation of those around them. It has come to my attention that some people think that Odysseus is not a hero, which is a completely perplexing statement that is wrong in every single way. Now, you might be thinking to yourself, “well Jackson, that’s a narrow minded point of view and I am too uninformed of your perspective to understand”: well, in order to understand my perspective, one must acknowledge that the majority of situations Odysseus was put into was a result of the Gods or some other force, not his own. While there were some instances in which Odysseus’ punishment was a direct result of his fatal characteristics, it can be concluded that Odysseus himself did more good for himself and those closest to him, and can be characterized as a hero. Throughout the course of the Odyssey, Odysseus makes both heroic decisions and fatal mistakes, yet is still one of the most well recognized heroes of Greek literature. Welcome to my Ted Talk.
Odysseus can be classified as a hero due to his willingness to get his men back aboard his ship from the Lotus Eaters. When Odysseus and his men dock at the land of the Lotus Eaters, his men were quickly exposed to the Lotus fruit, and “lost all desire to return home, with their only wish being to linger with the Lotus eaters, grazing on Lotus”(107). Yet, Odysseus recognized this and brought them back to his ships, where he made them all rest and get back to their duties the next day, reminding them of why they had to go home and why they wanted to go home: exemplifying his genuine care for the lives and futures of his men, and bestows a certain wisdom that one has to endure pain in the present to experience a prosperous future. While Odysseus could have easily left his men to rot in the land of the Lotus eaters, he instead took his men back to fulfill their lives and futures back in Ithaca: once again exemplifying the genuine concern and good leadership that Odysseus displays throughout the course of the Odyssey. Odysseus displays his good leadership in that he single handedly prevented a numerous amount of his men from spending/wasting the rest of their lives on the land of the Lotus eaters.
Odysseus also displays his sharp intellect in his conflict with Polyphemus on the island of the Cyclops. Odysseus and his men are raiding the giant’s home when the giant comes back and traps them, eating several of Odysseus’ men in the process. In order to escape the wrath of Pilyphemus, Odysseus gets the giant drunk and doesn’t reveal his true identity to the menace of society: stating that his name was “nobody”. When Odysseus finally attacks the giant, Polyphemus is caught off guard and needs assistance from his fellow giants: however, in his cry of help, Polyphemus states that “Nobody’s killing me now by fraud and not by force!” (224), which meant that the giant would not receive any help from his comrades. Odysseus single handedly won his conflict with Polyphemus due to his wits and quick decision making, saving himself and his crew from a certain gruesome death. Odysseus can be considered a hero because he single handedly guided his crew and himself in a situation that could have easily resulted in the death of every member of his crew, yet he guided himself and his crew to safety with ease and intellect.
While the points that I have previously mentioned above highlight Odysseus’ godly leadership qualities, there are still some who believe that Odysseus is not the hero that the Odyssey portrays him to be. However, I can say with confidence that this statement is false and is blasphemous. For example, one might argue that Odysseus was to blame for letting his men slaughter the cattle of the sun, resulting in the deaths of all of his crew members and the destruction of his ship, and that this even happened because of his poor leadership qualities and restraint on his crew. Nevertheless, there is solid evidence as to why Odysseus is not responsible for his men’s slaughter of the cattle of the sun. For instance, when Odysseus and his men dock on the side of the island of Helios, Odysseus himself warns his men about the prophecy he received from Tiresias: stating that if they “come on a herd of cattle or fine flock of sheep, not one man among us, blind in his reckless ways, will slaughter an ox or ram.” (280). Odysseus himself warned his own men against killing any animals on the island of Helios, and tried to prevent them from indulging in their temptations to do so: yet they betrayed Odysseus’ trust anyway and killed the Cattle of Sun. Furthermore, some criticize Odysseus’ decision to go to sleep and leave his crew unsupervised: however, Odysseus himself did not go to sleep voluntarily but was rather put to sleep by the gods, which renders the argument that his influence for his men was weak, because he physically could not stop them from killing the cattle of the sun. Therefore, it can be concluded that the deaths of Odysseus’ crew was completely out of his control and does not demonstrate poor leadership skills on Odysseus’ end, but rather the lack of temptation his crew contained.
An article by Jeff Dolan debunks the true meaning of a hero, and states that every hero has flaws but at the end of the day, they are remembered for their accomplishments and brave actions, and not for their flaws. Every hero, from Achilles to Chris Bumstead all have special defining characteristics and have all undergone their own journeys to success, despite having numerous flaws in their characters. We see that Odysseus has two defining flaws of recklessness and hubris, represented in his call to Polyphemus, but at the end of the day, Odysseus is remembered in Greek literature for his cunningness and heroic journey back to Ithaca. In conclusion, Homer’s Odyssey displays both positive and negative human qualities through Odysseus, yet we still consider him a hero because he displays the qualities of a hero, yet is flawed and showcases human tendencies.